Shop with Peace of Mind


100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We want all of our customers to be 100% satisfied with their purchase and there experience. If you for any reason we did not meet your needs or give you our “WOW” experience please click here to email us your feedback.


30 Day Money Back Guarantee

Have peace of mind when purchasing from Distinctive Diamonds that for any reason within 30 days you can return and receive your money back on your purchase with no questions asked. Custom jewelry and special orders are excluded from the money back guarantee.


Free Lifetime Jewelry Maintenance

Our service does not end when you walk out the door with your purchase. You do not pay for our warranty. It automatically comes with your purchase.  When you buy jewelry from us, we provide you with a Lifetime Warranty. All we ask from you is that you bring your ring into us every six months to keep your Warranty active.  That allows us to check for damage you may not be able to see and prevent breakage, damage, or loss from happening.  Our no cost warranty includes: Details: Click Here


Unbeatable Price Guarantee

Distinctive Diamonds guarantee’s to be the best price on loose diamonds when comparing apples to apples. Were happy to prove this to you by showing you our Rapaport Diamond Report on any stone you are considering purchasing. Much like the auto industry’s Blue Book, the Rapaport Diamond Report is a closely guarded industry wholesale pricing sheet, showing wholesale diamond prices around the world. Even up to 30 days after your purchase if you find a diamond anywhere in the United States within the same grading laboratory and specifics, at a lower price, Distinctive Diamonds will match the price, or we’ll refund your money.


Lifetime Upgrade

Any loose diamond purchased from Distinctive Diamonds you can trade in for life, and receive 100% on what you paid towards another diamond. Unlike traditional jewelry stores you do not have to double the purchase when upgrading, you only pay the difference. If you buy a $2,000 diamond and find a diamond later down the road for $2200, you only pay the $200 difference.


Largest Selection in the Country

Distinctive Diamonds is a direct diamond importer, offering hand-picked exquisite diamonds cutters. Our president, Eli Benisty grew up in the diamond industry in Tel Aviv, Israel, surrounded by the diamond cutters and brokers in one of the world’s largest diamond exchange centers. For years, Eli worked as a wholesaler, supplying diamonds to jewelry stores here in the Midwest. Through this experience, he saw an opportunity to eliminate unnecessary markups and sell direct to the consumer. His vision was to provide the highest quality diamonds at significantly better values in a more comfortable, no pressure, no risk shopping environment.