Trusted Jewelry Store in Indianapolis

Our store offers a unique buying experience due to our dedication to client education and quality customer service. Distinctive Diamonds carries the most sought-after jewelry inventory in the state and sells all items at the lowest prices.

World Class Customer Service

As part of our bid to be the best jewelry store Indianapolis has to offer, Distinctive Diamonds makes quality customer service the number one priority. This is backed by friendly and knowledgeable staff that are always happy to answer any questions that you may have.

Distinctive Diamonds will assist you in a manner that no other jewelry stores in Indianapolis can: by educating you about the diamonds and showing you why you’re getting them at the lowest prices anywhere across the nation.

Smart Purchases

We aim to be the kind of jewelry store Indianapolis buyers can count on for smart purchases. We assist all clients in making sure they know they get maximum quality at minimum costs. This is accomplished through the use of the Diamond Rapaport Report. The Diamond Rapaport Report is not typically revealed to the public; however, owner Eli Benisty saw it fit to show clients how our chosen diamonds are priced all over the world, giving you the assurance of transparency and fair pricing.

Unique Inventory

Not many jewelry stores in Indianapolis can attest that their diamonds are their own. Distinctive Diamonds has a large collection of prime diamonds in stock all the way from Israel. The store’s owner, Eli Benisty, regularly goes home to his native Israel to gather diamonds from his family’s diamond-cutting company to bring them back to the U.S.

These diamonds are guaranteed of certification by three independent gemological laboratories: the Gemological Institute of America, the European Gemological Laboratory and the American Gem Society. These gemological laboratories grade all the diamonds from our inventory to ensure that our clients receive only the highest in quality standards.

We make sure you present your loved one with the best jewelry and diamonds on that special occasion for memories that last a lifetime. Visit our store at 8555 North River Road, Suite 470, Indianapolis, IN today!