Custom Jewelry

Don’t see precisely what you’re looking for?

Everyone wants to own the perfect piece of jewelry. We realize, however, that even the most popular designs available in today’s market may not match your tastes precisely. From stunning diamond rings to gorgeous pendants, we can help you create the perfect addition to your jewelry box.

Tell us what you’ve got in mind and we’ll do our best to find it through our wide range of jewelry services, or we can custom-make a design especially for you. Distinctive Diamonds will make your dream ring a reality.  Make an appointment with us by clicking here.


Custom Design Your Ring

At Distinctive Diamonds, designing a custom piece of jewelry costs nothing more than the jewelry in our cases. There is no design up-charge. This way, you can give your beloved the perfect piece of jewelry, yet still be in control of the amount you spend.

Starting the Custom Design process is easy:

1. Schedule an appointment with our designer.

2. Bring in photos, tear sheets, and sketches of what you want to help inspire your design.

3. We’ll discuss your ideas and develop a concept that fits your budget.

4. Within 48 hours we will have a 3D image of the perfect ring you’re designing.

5. Distinctive Diamonds will stay within your budget and create a piece of jewelry that is uniquely yours.

6. In about a month, your custom jewelry will be ready to wear.

So, no worries; enjoy the design process! It’s fun, creative and hassle-free.

Choose Among The Best Diamonds

To create a truly beautiful and high-quality piece of jewelry, one must use the best materials. We take great pride in our collection of diamonds, which just happens to be the largest privately-owned diamond inventory not just in Indianapolis, IN but in the entire Midwest.

Our Engagement Story

"After a picture perfect engagement at the Eiffel Tower; the search was on for the perfect engagement ring! I did extensive research, read reviews, called, and e-mailed nearly every jewelry store in Indianapolis, and Carmel areas. I decided Distinctive Diamonds of Indianapolis was the place for me. I’ll let my story illustrate why.

A native Hoosier, I was going to be out of the country for the entire process. This presented some unique challenges. Megan from Distinctive Diamonds eased my concerns immediately by being very prompt and always available to communicate. 

I called and gave a wide range of specifics for the loose diamond I was looking for; shortly after I received an e-mail listing multiple diamonds available. I selected 3 stones that really caught my eye, based on the 4 C's along with pricing (which was significantly lower than other jewelry stores for comparable diamonds). The next day to my surprise, I received a video by e-mail comparing the three stones, along with GIA certificates for each. This was far beyond my expectations!

Distinctive diamonds was a finalist, and I scheduled an appointment with Megan to have my fiancee and I's parents visit the store in person to see the diamonds. Once the meeting was underway I was able to FaceTime into the meeting like I was actually there! The diamond and customer service were great, and there was no need to visit other shops in town, we’d found the right one.

Finally came the custom setting, and I had a vision in mind of how the ring would look. It was clear that Megan was determined to make it match my vision exactly. We went back and forth exchanging multiple e-mails with my drawings, along with the 3D images, and drawings produced by Distinctive Diamonds. I was rather picky, and Megan was patient throughout the process until we got it just right!

We finalized the ring for a price under my budget, with no hidden fees attached. The ring will be finished with a turnaround time much shorter than I expected and I can’t wait for my soon to be wife to see it in person. She’ll absolutely love it! I couldn’t be happier with the customer experience provided by Distinctive Diamonds. The perfect ring became a reality!"

Kurt Cunningham

Custom Engagement Ring